Drugstore Beauty Buys Suddenly Outselling Luxury Must-Haves for Busy Adults

Published Saturday May 3 2025 by Estée Monroe

Lips on a Budget: Drugstore Lipsticks and Plumpers

A group of diverse busy adults applying or holding affordable lipsticks and lip plumpers in a modern indoor setting with a display of beauty products on a countertop.

I keep grabbing Maybelline at the checkout when I’m just there for bananas. Why is there lipstick by the fruit? I don’t know, but I fall for it every time. The glazed, plump lip thing—scroll Instagram for five seconds, there it is, but now it’s all drugstore stuff, not those fancy tubes that snap shut like a spaceship. My wallet’s not sure how to feel about this.

Hydrating Formulas for All-Day Wear

Ever tried putting on lipstick while steering with your knee? Yeah, me too, and I’m not proud. I get so annoyed when these so-called “hydrating” lipsticks dry out faster than my phone at 2%. e.l.f. O Face, NYX Butter Lipstick—cheap, but they’re supposed to have hyaluronic acid or shea butter. I don’t check until someone at work says, “Hey, you look…dewy?” and then I’m squinting at the ingredients like it’ll reveal my secrets.

It’s weird—sometimes “moisturized and plump” just means sticky, but Maybelline’s Super Stay is more like magic glue, the kind that doesn’t bail mid-sandwich. Tinted balms from the drugstore are everywhere. I toss them in every bag, so now I find three at once and forget if I even have cash with me.

Quick chart, because I can’t keep track and nobody else can either:

Brand Key Hydrators Finish Price ($)
e.l.f. Hyaluronic Acid Satin Under 10
Maybelline Vitamin E Matte 8-12
NYX Shea Butter Creamy 10-ish

Every shade costs less than a taco. I can’t find my receipts anyway.

Trending Lip Plumpers

Plumpers are everywhere, still, and I guess that’s just how it is now. Under $15, these things are as common as those “best summer songs” playlists. I keep grabbing Pixi gloss thinking it’s my usual, then—bam—tingle city, and my lips look like I got spooked. Nobody told me about the tingle.

Most are clear, some are “peach something,” and every tube swears you’ll see fuller lips in seconds. Cinnamon? Menthol? I have no clue. The tingle means it’s working, I guess. Elf and Maybelline drop new shades constantly, and half the time they’re next to old mascara nobody wants.

Found this accidental stash in my bathroom:

  • e.l.f. Lip Plumping Gloss – under $10, shiny but doesn’t glue my lips to my coffee mug.
  • Maybelline Lifter Gloss – hyaluronic acid, I think? Tastes a little sweet, doesn’t sting.
  • Pixi LipLift Max – minty, which makes meetings less boring.

None of them survive tacos. Reapplying feels sneaky though. Sometimes I check the mirror to see if my lips went balloon mode, but nobody ever says anything.

Body Care Heroes: Affordable Solutions for Soft Skin

I swear, the cheapest body wash always ends up on my shelf even after I promise myself “something fancy next time.” Soft skin? It’s just whatever doesn’t leave me itchy or sticky. Some of these body washes have ingredient lists longer than frozen dinners. I still don’t know what a “serum body wash” is supposed to do, but they’re everywhere.

Choosing the Right Body Wash

I get stuck in front of the body wash wall, all shouting “hydration” or “micellar cleansing” (what?). If “shea butter” is in huge font, I figure it’s for dry skin, but then I remember my neighbor ate shampoo once because it smelled like frosting. I look for “gentle” or “fragrance-free,” but sometimes the cheap stuff just lathers better. Store brand in a jug? Sure, that’s self-care now. Dove and Cetaphil, always on the edge of affordable and “wait, is this receipt right?” It’s a mess.

  • Look for: Ceramides, oatmeal, aloe—no idea why, but it’s always on the “sensitive” stuff.
  • Skip: Anything tingly. Shaved legs and tingles? Disaster.
  • Random: Why does grapefruit body wash smell like candy? No answers.

Benefits of Serum Body Washes

Serum body washes—did they mean to put those by the face creams? They’re loaded with stuff from expensive moisturizers but for the shower. Hyaluronic acid, niacinamide—do those even do anything in 14 seconds? My elbows feel less like sandpaper, so maybe.

I bought one with “vitamin E infusion” on the label, convinced my arms looked shinier for a week, but maybe it was just the bad lighting. These don’t lather much, so I use more. Is that the point? I’m not opening Excel for a table, so here’s a janky one:

Claim My Result
“Deep hydration” Skin feels slippery
“Glowing skin” Slightly less dull
“Firming complex” Can’t tell

They’re a couple bucks more, and then I hide them from guests for no reason. Serum body wash is everywhere now, Target, Walmart, whatever. I keep buying them, maybe just because my towels snag less. Probably not related.